Why Many Creatives Don’t Want to Work on Female-Focused Campaigns

And how NYC's new Joan agency plans to change that

Headshot of Patrick Coffee

CANNES, France—Creative agency Joan launched in New York this year with a very specific goal: providing clients with a more flexible approach to marketing by surrounding principals Jaime Robinson and Lisa Clunie with a rotating cast of creative and production staffers so they can nimbly serve each client in an increasingly project-based marketplace. General Mills is the shop's first account.

Joan is also relatively unique as an agency led by two women, and its mission statement notes that its name was "inspired by all of the Joans throughout history who have brought big changes to the world." Adweek spoke to Robinson (Wieden + Kennedy, Pereira & O'Dell) and Clunie (Refinery29, Ogilvy & Mather) at the Cannes Festival of Creativity to discuss their approach to the agency model and the current state of advertising to both men and women.

Do you think agencies view work targeted to women differently than work targeted to men?

Jaime Robinson: In the creative industry, we all bring our personal experiences to the table—that's where all of our creative juice comes from. But I don't think enough energy is being put into work for women. It's sad, because when a brief comes in for a women's brand to an agency, most of the creatives run. As someone who's run two creative departments at great agencies, [I can say that] it's harder to get people to work on a women's brand than a men's brand. Oftentimes, there's a fear that it won't amount to good work because the tendency is to be more conservative. Watch any daytime TV program: It's either wallpaper for pretty people or it's wallpaper for cleaning people.

Does Joan see itself as a female-focused agency?

Robinson: Only 20 [percent] to 25 percent of our work is targeted toward women, while 75 percent is general market. But we are excited about the opportunity to make this sort of work better. Our thought is, let's bring in the most diverse group of creative minds we can find and target it to whatever audience.

What do you think of the Association of National Advertisers' recent #SeeHer push for more accurate portrayals of women in ads?

Robinson: That is important, but if you really want to "see her," you should acknowledge that she has a brain. When you create work that acknowledges that she can laugh and you care to give her the best kind of work you can give her, that's the most important thing.

Lisa Clunie: A woman can tell a dirty joke as well as anyone. We're not all into yoga, dance and beaches. That's true of men, too: they're not all jock-y football types.

Over the past few months, we've reported on several agencies with "rotating cast" models similar to yours, like San Francisco's Partners in Crime and Erich & Kallman. Is this a trend?

Clunie: Yes. When working with so many different brands, it's difficult to pull together a static team that can play all those parts. Because I came from Refinery29 and Jaime came from W+K, we're attracting a bizarre mix of clients that include lots of packaged-goods companies, classic brands that want giant campaign ideas, and fashion brands. But if we're doing something for a luxury brand, we can't use the people from the consumer goods side very well. Clients also want more project work, and talent doesn't necessarily want to stick to [what they've worked on] before either—people would like more flexible lives. We don't have account people and planners in the traditional way: We have blurry lines. A lot of the people we're meeting are Swiss Army Knives, and that's better for us.

How will you combine your histories working for traditional creative agencies and an editorial publication well known for its native advertising unit?

Clunie: Imagine that you have a brand that needs to live in the social space, so you hire a social agency. They're typically excellent at handling the editorial calendar, taking advantage of blips in culture, et cetera. Traditional agencies, on the other hand, bring big campaign ideas and strategies but typically haven't been as good at distributing content or understanding platforms and how they interrelate in terms of optimizing the work. Joan lives in the middle. We come up with big brand ideas based on insights, then disseminate the resulting story through all the modern channels. Some of the key roles in that equation are audience growth, content strategy and analytics.

The two of you had never worked together in the agency world. What made you decide to launch Joan?

Robinson: We'd known each other through email for years, and when we met face to face we really just hit it off. Lisa is a businessperson who is insanely creative while I'm a creative with some business sense. We started talking about the place we wanted to build, and everything overlapped.

Clunie: I was obsessed with her work and thought, who is this person? I'm most passionate about helping brands grow, and going to Refinery29 was a little like going in-house. While that was super fun, I needed to be more involved with multiple brands. 

What about your Foundation of Diversity, which you set up to donate a portion of profits to advocacy groups while providing each employee with a financial stake in the company?

Clunie: We will invest a portion of our profit and time, but we need to measure what difference it makes—and we want to publish that information. We want to demonstrate to the industry that it's not enough to just hire a chief diversity officer and do anti-harassment training. That's important, but the action is what really matters: How many people did you hire? How many did you train? How are you leaving the industry better than you found it?

@PatrickCoffee patrick.coffee@adweek.com Patrick Coffee is a senior editor for Adweek.
Publish date: June 21, 2016 https://dev.adweek.com/brand-marketing/why-many-creatives-dont-want-work-female-focused-campaigns-172148/ © 2020 Adweek, LLC. - All Rights Reserved and NOT FOR REPRINT