Here’s Why U.S. Ad-Tech Leaders Are Often Unsuccessful in China

Nevertheless, even globally successful companies fall flat in China. So, why do some Western firms do well in the country while others fail miserably?

Some of the world’s biggest companies have encountered tremendous difficulties or outright failure in their China expansion plans, with Facebook and Google as just two examples. While government preference toward local firms is only part of the reason, that rationale alone doesn’t explain the whole picture. Other roadblocks that have stood in the way include language barrier, high entry fees for U.S. businesses and tough local market nuances. Foreign firms often trip up on some of these key customs and business traits.

Guanxi

Guanxi is the Chinese term for business relationships. In China, business success is often determined more by who you know versus what you do and how your product or service is different. While the U.S. has a very diplomatic business culture, in China it’s much more direct and frank. 

“I fought the law, and the law won”

This is a key lesson for any business that elects to enter the Chinese market. While government entities in the U.S. may be more inclined toward a laissez-faire attitude of regulating businesses, that is not the case in China typically. A “move fast and break things” mentality doesn’t work well.

Distinctive local customs and habits

In many Western nations, companies succeed through niche targeting and are known to be good at connecting with specific groups of people exclusively. This approach doesn’t work in China, as it’s a market built on scale. Chinese customers typically don’t expect perfection, instead preferring mass appeal. A recent research study identifies a lack of understanding of local market conditions are one of the three most common ways Western digital-focused firms fail in China.

Not innovative enough

The Chinese market is rapidly evolving and has proven to have a large appetite for new products and services. Companies that succeed in this market are constantly innovating and often release new products at least two to four times a year, a much faster pace than in the U.S. or Europe.

For example, consider the rise of smart TVs and OTT in China versus the rest of the world. In 2017, 45 percent of households in China had a smart TV while just under 29 percent of households in the U.S. had a dedicated smart TV device. Chinese manufacturers like Skyworth and Hisense subsidize smart TV prices through advertising, enabling them to reach a wide audience through affordable hardware costs without losing out on revenue. 

Bujie diqi

This Mandarin phrase roughly means “keep their feet firmly on the ground.” In short, many Western firms have entered China—or attempted to enter the market—thinking that it would be a fairly simple process and that their globally dominating technology would make a big splash in this market. But this kind of hubris fails to take local innovations, the relative lack of name recognition and the hyper-competitive local market into account. 

Market size

In many spaces, Western firms are caught off guard by the sheer number of competitors they go up against in China. While big tech companies had to best at most hundreds or dozens of competitors in North America, Feng Li, a professor at City University of London’s Cass Business School, noted that the same firm will have thousands of competitors or more in China. Businesses that fail to appreciate the scope of the local market are unlikely to emerge victorious over savvier firms.

Companies looking to expand into China have to take careful and considerate measures to make it a successful entry. Applying a mobile-first and mobile only strategy is key, as a vast majority of Chinese internet users go online via mobile devices and apps. Trying to shoehorn a desktop-based system into such a landscape is fraught with perils. For example, consider the rise of micro apps, apps within super apps like Alipay. In particular, WeChat alone has 580,000 apps within its own app environment, highlighting the mobile-centric nature of China.

Any company with expansion plans should choose its China team very strategically by hiring staff with both international experience as well as local knowledge to create a local and autonomous team. Not only should individuals have a deep understanding of the country, but they should also be given wide leeway to implement products and methodologies specifically with China in mind. Companies see growth in China when efforts are spearheaded by those who know the market well and are enabled with the flexibility necessary to adapt.

While many companies see China as one large market, this fails to take into account local and regional nuances and needs. China is a very diverse and geographically vast country with preferences and needs varying by and even within provinces. Firms can succeed if they carefully consider their expansion plans by province and city.

While joint ventures can be tempting for foreign businesses since they eliminate operational burdens, they leave the international company at the mercy of Chinese partners. Companies should be selectively open to collaboration. Firms are best avoiding this temptation; however, this doesn’t mean collaboration with local players shouldn’t happen at all. For example, partnerships with local Chinese analytics firms can be fruitful and can be an advantage to companies looking to expand into China. It can also help Chinese firms expand operations overseas.

This is especially the case with ad buying in China versus the U.S., as the Chinese market has huge trust issues. While U.S. advertisers and agencies rely heavily on third-party verification, advertisers in China prefer to experiment with publisher audiences to see for themselves what will work best for their agenda.

As one eBay executive noted, “It’s death by a thousand cuts” when it comes to China. Businesses need to do lots of things right in order to get a foothold and succeed in the country.

Chinese operations can be enormously successful, so long as expansion occurs in a thoughtful and diligent manner with their needs front of mind. As always, the customer is always right. Companies must be respectful of local laws and customs surrounding business and let those who deeply and thoroughly know the Chinese market lead initiatives. For ad-tech companies to be successful, they must make China a main focus: Don’t let the market be an afterthought.